Pigeon Point is located on the coast and is somewhat offshore when spots to the north are blown out. While some folks claim there are rights that can be caught during big south swells, those swells are rare in this area. Others have mentioned that there's a notable right that breaks outside the point on certain Maverick's days. There are a few small reef breaks along the cliffs on the south side that some surfers might opt for instead.

The surf here can handle swell sizes ranging from about 3 feet (1 meter) to 10 feet (3 meters), mainly during the summer and autumn months. The best swell directions to expect are from the south, south-southwest, and southwest, along with west and west-southwest. Most of the waves break over a mix of sand and some rock, with wave types being mostly reef. The preferred wind directions are from the north and northeast, and the best tides are low to medium. Surfing here can accommodate various skill levels, from beginners to experts, making it a mixed bag in terms of experience.

Access to Pigeon Point is easy, right off the road, but you might wonder why you'd want to surf here at all. Crowds are basically nonexistent, which gives you plenty of space in the water. There's a laid-back local vibe, although you probably won't run into many locals while surfing. Just keep in mind that the environment is clean, but there are potential hazards like loneliness and sharks to consider.